OBJECTIVE: To investigate risk factors and outcomes and to develop a cogent perioperative management algorithm for dural defects (DDs) in anterior surgery for cervical ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL). METHODS: Ninety OPLL patients who had undergone anterior cervical decompression between January 2014 and December 2016 were reviewed. DDs occurred in 12 patients. Demographic, clinical, and radiologic data; intraoperative and postoperative management; and complications were analyzed. Risk factors for DDs were assessed with multivariate analysis. A treatment algorithm was identified based on these findings and our experience. RESULTS: The prevalence of DDs was 13.3% (12/90). Univariate and multivariate analyses showed that the ratio of OPLL base to spinal canal (odds ratio [OR] 1.09, P=0.012), kyphotic cervical alignment with thick OPLL masses (OR 9.44, P=0.026), and lateral, curved, and irregular OPLL masses (OR 8.28, P=0.037) could be risk factors for DDs. DDs were repaired intraoperatively with onlay grafts, and lumbar drains were placed in all DD patients. The treatment was successful in all DD patients, and outcome measures did not differ between the DD and no DD groups. No patient had experienced complications associated with DDs and CSF leaks at the final follow-up visit. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with broad-based OPLL, kyphotic cervical alignment with thick OPLL masses, and lateral, curved, and irregular OPLL masses have a higher risk of DD in anterior surgery for OPLL. Intraoperative primary repair with onlay grafts combined with early lumbar drains is a simple, safe, and effective strategy for DDs. The outlook for the long-term sequelae of DDs is optimistic if they are managed adequately.