Background The existing classification in Chiari I malformation (CM-I) has limited significance for the selection of surgical methods. Objective The purpose of this study was to investigate the surgery of CM-I with syringomyelia based on the high-resolution MR imaging (HRMRI) findings. Methods Data from 115 patients were collected and retrospectively analyzed. For those with syringomyelia up to the level of C1, HRMRI was performed and according to the communication status between the fourth ventricle and the syringomyelia, patients can be divided into four types, namely Type A: classic communicating; Type B: partial communicating; Type C: non-communicating; Type D: atrophic. All operations were performed with Foramen magnum and Magendie dredging (FMMD), and all intradural factors that may have induced the obstruction of CSF circulation were recorded. The efficiency of operation on syringomyelia was evaluated by mJOA, imaging findings, and complications in the follow-up periods. Results The postoperative follow-up period was from 12 to 24 months, with an average of 14.3 months. At 1 year, the mJOA of 115 patients was significantly higher than that before the operations (before surgery 12.1 +/- 2.3 vs. after surgery 14. 2 +/- 1.4, P < 0.05). In addition, postoperative re-examination showed that the size of the syringomyelia was reduced or completely resolved in patients of Type A, 100% (2/2); Type B, 81% (9/11); Type C, 84% (81/97); and Type D, 20% (1/5). Conclusions According to our new classification based on HRMRI, FMMD is the key to surgical treatment, especially for Type A and Type B patients.